Symphony No. 2 sample
performed by the Sydney Symphony Orchestra conducted by Stuart Challender
184.108.40.206 - 220.127.116.11 - timp, 4pc, hp, cel - strings
duration 20:00 © 1988 Wise Music Group
Performed by the Sydney Symphony Orchestra conducted by Stuart Challender on the ABC Classics CD Carl Vine - Complete Symphonies 1-6
on iTunes: 
Buy a copy of the score
Also see: Orchestral
This work is written in a single movement made up of five contrasting sections, beginning with a passage of great rhythmic momentum. Restless ostinati in the lower strings and woodwinds seem to try to break free from the spell of the 'D' which is the central tonal focus of the work. A characteristic theme soon appears high above this texture - in long notes, it is simple and diatonic, luminously scored for high strings doubled by piccolo. The pitches used here are crucial to the work's development, particularly the G and B flat which we hear often. Other instruments take up these floating phrases, travelling in pairs : flute doubles muted trumpet, piccolo subtly brightens the solo horn, while tension builds with the progressive addition of overlapping ostinati throughout the orchestra.
This tension is released with the arrival of a new 'paragraph', characteristic of Vine's style : a 12/8 ostinato for harp (now centring on C sharp) stabilises the continuing scurrying motives from the opening, while the oboe announces a new, simple, stepwise melody. Again the section explores the potential tension, albeit genially, between groupings of two and three, and comes to a moment of repose in E major before the violent outburst of the second section. At this point we hear one of the rare appearances of automobile brake drums and suspension springs in symphonic music. The arresting chords give way to a passage built on rising scalar figures which eventually leads to another passage where a harp ostinato (this time supporting themes related to those heard above the opening texture) inaugurates another gathering of texture before a return to the chords which open the section.
The third section contains a greater diversity of material, with numerous short motives flying about in a transparent orchestral texture. The fourth section corresponds to a traditional slow movement, where various instruments are given extensive lyrical solos (beginning, for instance, with the cello). A short bridge passage, where the cor anglais recalls the opening melody, leads into an extraordinarily lush flowering of the texture : here is the crystal of the work, and in a sense its climax because it is here that the work recapitulates much of its earlier material, but in a concentrated form which focuses our perception of the relationships between seemingly disparate rhythmic passages. Having made these connections, the piece ends in a short fast coda, based on entirely new material.
© Gordon Kerry 1991
Symphony No. 2 was commissioned by the Australian Broadcasting Commission with assistance from the Australian Bicentennial Authority, and was premiered by Hiroyuki Iwaki and the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra in April 1988.
Vine, whose Symphony No. 2 opened the program, is a young man who has absorbed a great many contemporary musical influences and managed to combine them in a way that reflects his times and his own musical thought. His symphony is imaginative and ingenious, well scored, and thoroughly persuasive ... [Robert C. Marsh, Chicago Sun-Times, Nov 3, 1988] ... there is not the slightest doubt that this symphony is a finely made and important work. the orchestral scoring is exceptionally graceful and attractive, and there is not a minute of the work which does not show at work a fruitful and deeply musical mind. [Kenneth Hince, The Melbourne Age, April 25, 1988]